“The bad novelist constructs his characters; he directs them and makes them speak. The true novelist listens to them and watches them act; he hears their voices even before he knows them.” (Jon Winokur, Advice to Writers)
That’s the whole craft problem stated plainly. One kind of writer decides in advance what will happen and forces the character to say it. The other kind waits, pays attention, and writes down what was already there.
You can feel the difference from the outside. Forced dialogue exists to move a scene along, and you can hear the writer’s vocabulary underneath the character’s voice. Discovered dialogue feels like eavesdropping. The character has opinions you didn’t plan, a laugh that’s wrong for the moment, a word they keep repeating, a refusal to do what the outline needs.
Most writers don’t start in the second mode. You get there by spending time with a character outside the demands of plot, just to hear how they sound.
Here’s a way to practice that today.
Writing exercise (15 to 30 minutes)
Pick a character, yours or one you’re developing. Put them in a room, alone. Someone they’re waiting for is late.
Write only what they do and say while they wait. Let them talk to themselves, fidget, get annoyed, change their mind about whether to sit, stand, or text the person who’s late. Don’t direct them toward a point.
When you’re done, read it back and ask one question. Does this sound like them, or does it sound like you?
If you would like to learn more about the craft behind storytelling, my articles on Ramos On Craft go deeper every Tuesday and Thursday. Subscribe here
Rolando Andrés Ramos 
Leave a comment