“There should be a name for this moment in a story when, a situation having been established, a new character arrives. We automatically expect that new element to alter or complicate or deepen the situation.” (George Saunders, A Swim in a Pond in the Rain)
Writing Exercise: The Power of Arrival in Storytelling
Techniques Illustrated by the Quotation:
1. Dynamic Character Introduction: A new character’s arrival should shift or complicate the established situation. This could be done through their behavior, backstory, or purpose.
2. Tension and Stakes: The arrival should heighten tension, raise stakes, or deepen the narrative conflict, even subtly.
3. Integration into the Narrative: The new character must feel organic, fitting naturally into the story while still adding surprise or complexity.
Writing Prompt (500 Words):
Imagine a scene where two characters are engaged in an activity (e.g., preparing a meal, waiting for a storm to pass, or handling a minor conflict). The relationship and stakes between them should be clearly established within the first 200 words. Then, introduce a third character who arrives unexpectedly. This character’s arrival must alter the dynamics—whether through direct conflict, hidden motives, or even subtle emotional shifts. Consider how the newcomer interacts with the established characters and how their presence reshapes the scene.
Constraints:
• Avoid making the third character a blatant antagonist or deus ex machina. Aim for complexity and nuance.
• Use dialogue and body language to reveal tension rather than stating it outright.
• Conclude the scene with a clear but unresolved shift in the power dynamics.
Evaluation Criteria:
A Strong Response:
• Dynamic Character Introduction: The new character is vividly described, with distinct traits and motivations that complicate the situation in believable ways.
• Heightened Tension and Stakes: The arrival significantly alters the mood, relationships, or stakes of the scene. This change feels earned, not contrived.
• Seamless Integration: The third character’s introduction feels natural and connected to the context, deepening the story rather than distracting from it.
• Show, Don’t Tell: Tension is conveyed through subtext, gestures, and dialogue rather than heavy-handed narration.
Example of Strong Introduction:
Two old friends are fixing a car on a quiet evening. When one friend’s estranged sibling shows up unannounced, they don’t directly confront them but instead start fiddling with a tool, their silence bristling with decades of unspoken tension.
A Weak Response:
• Flat Introduction: The new character’s entrance feels arbitrary or clichéd, with little effort to make them distinct or engaging.
• Low Stakes: The arrival has no meaningful impact on the dynamics or plot, leaving the scene static.
• Jarring Integration: The new character feels forced into the scene, breaking immersion rather than enhancing it.
Example of Weak Introduction:
Two coworkers are debating a project when a delivery person bursts in, delivers a package, and leaves. The newcomer’s role is superficial and doesn’t affect the central characters.
Follow-Up Questions for Workshopping/Revision:
1. Does the new character have a distinct motivation or backstory hinted at through their words or actions?
2. How does their arrival subtly or overtly shift the dynamics between the original characters?
3. Are there moments of subtext or tension that could be heightened further?
4. Is the third character’s introduction surprising but still believable within the story’s context?
5. What would happen if the scene continued—how might the characters’ relationships evolve?
Recommended Reading:
• “Everything That Rises Must Converge” by Flannery O’Connor: O’Connor masterfully introduces new characters in ways that deepen existing tension and themes.
• “The Dead” by James Joyce: Gabriel’s interaction with Gretta in the later part of the story exemplifies how a character can reframe the entire emotional landscape of a narrative through subtle dynamics.
Leave a comment