“So perhaps it’s not ten thousand hours of practice that counts; maybe it’s ten thousand hours of consumption.” (Nick Hornby, Dickens and Prince)
Writing Exercise: Mastery Through Imitation and Consumption
Techniques Illustrated by the Quotation:
1. Deliberate Imitation as a Learning Tool – Studying and replicating the techniques of great writers builds skill and deepens understanding of craft.
2. Active Reading and Analysis – Mastery of writing comes not just from producing work but from consuming literature with a critical, writerly eye.
3. Transformation Through Absorption – True originality emerges not from isolation but from synthesizing influences into a unique voice.
Writing Prompt:
Select a passage (250-500 words) from a writer whose style you admire. This could be a section from a novel, a short story, or even an essay. Read it not as a reader but as a writer dissecting the craft choices. Consider sentence structure, rhythm, diction, and the balance of exposition and action.
Then, write a new 500-word passage using that style as a model but applied to your own subject matter. Do not copy the content—only the technique. If the original passage features long, flowing sentences with lyrical imagery, mimic that. If it’s clipped and staccato, match the rhythm.
Finally, reflect briefly: What was difficult? What did you learn about the writer’s technique? Did this exercise expand your stylistic range?
Strong vs. Weak Responses:
• Strong: The imitation captures the essence of the original writer’s technique while applying it to an original scene. The writer understands not just surface elements but deeper mechanics of voice and structure.
Example: A writer mimics Joan Didion’s cool, detached tone in a scene about a breakup, maintaining her signature rhythm and precision.
• Weak: The response either strays too far from the original technique (losing the intended practice) or imitates mechanically without understanding why the choices work.
Example: A writer copies Hemingway’s short sentences but doesn’t grasp the subtlety of his implied emotion and subtext, resulting in dull or flat prose.
Evaluation Criteria:
• Faithfulness to the stylistic technique of the chosen writer.
• A clear, deliberate application of that technique to original subject matter.
• Evidence of analytical engagement with the passage, not just surface-level mimicry.
• A reflective component demonstrating awareness of craft development.
Follow-Up Questions for Workshopping/Revisions:
• What specific elements of the original writer’s technique were most challenging to replicate?
• Did the exercise make you notice any gaps in your own writing habits?
• How did the experience of imitating another writer’s style influence your sense of voice?
• What aspects of this borrowed technique might you integrate into your own work permanently?
Recommended Reading:
• Reading Like a Writer by Francine Prose – A deep dive into how writers learn from literary consumption.
• The Paris Review Interviews (various volumes) – Offers insights into how great writers develop craft through reading and imitation.
• A Moveable Feast by Ernest Hemingway – Explores Hemingway’s early years studying other writers and refining his voice through deliberate stylistic choices.
Leave a comment